Small(I will post) posts are not counted, to save time.
Starts off with flavor spec, 2 1/2 paragraphs as the first post. Is first
to mention(and believe me, it will be mentioned again) that factions will
still have different win conditions. Good activity for a first post, but
this isn't going to detirmine alignment.
Asks if there is a cult in his next post. Because we want ot be prepared,
and he just modded buffy. Now that is a nice discussion starter, and a
good thing for our flavor masters to answer. Town enough.
Agrees with mav, most people probably have a faction and an indepentent
win (AB) Not sure which should be trusted more (AA,or AB) but a
<b>lot</b> can be gathered from initial win-spec.
Closed set-ups make D1 hard, and agress with MR K that role-spec is really all we have in a closed set-up, and it is early sucm hunting.
Halfway through book, and gives ideas of mind control. Says that it is
probably house and independent, so likely AB. I'm seeing a trend with
this line of thinking.
Says english is strange, explains mixup with roots. Doesn't really like factions form book, but harkonnens are likely mafia.
Not sure where to go from here.
Quotes mavketls list about how factions can have players who aren't too
much of a part of it. Green lover says that there is a chance there isn't
a scum group, but instead several sks. He then goes off to list other
possibilities for this game. I hope people haven't tried to push one.
What better way to distance yourself from scum than to say the scum are
distant? But green says #1 is unlikely at the end, so that has made my
scumdar feel better.
Asks what will be revealed upon death. Nothing really there.
Starts stating that he knows NO flavor.
Now says he doesn't know flavor again. Meta-vote Mav. Probably conflicting factions, not his favorite, will be interesting. Not much content.
Silknor: A large amounth of rolespec, giving lists of who, and says Ben-gesseret may not be as atredis as mav says. Good post, lots of content in list form.
Doubts a cult, because the freyman already agreed with Paul, and they
weren't really recruited. Although paul could be a mason leader.
Says Harkonnians have been compared to Nazis, and Corinos aonly care
about power. And Atreides too could have scummy farts, although generally
Ben Gesserit cares about certain players, guild cares about sppice.
Freman care about the plantet, but COULT slide with Atredies.
Drowning the worms is possible, so players not out of picture entirely.
Walks without rhythm.
Says he will not root for but root out harkonnians.
Remember how I said adacores first post was big for the start?
Yeah. Lots of helpful flavor discussion, which could strike me as
townie-that is a lot of information for scum to give out in the first
post. Although until this point scum were undefinied. But this is a
really good first post. Wow. Town enough, but still need more than one
Replys to Mr.k, saying that she got the thought that harkonians were bad
due to the whole tourture thing.
Then she gives off the comment of how her list is right, but there are
probably good people in harkonean, or bad in atredis. (THIS is what
worried me before, because it could be setting up a defense early on,
say, if she was in one of these "scummy" factions.)
Says that she thinks people have a faction, and probably a more
independent win condition-Duke Leto and Lady Jessica may be mtalking to
each other, for examply. Also cops may get more info. And she also
doesn't get Big nose's example, that his win conditions are in conflict
with each other.
Says Ben Gesserit may have a few good atredis characters, and that flavor suggests the duke to be alive.
Replys to BN, saying that we can do both, and that is important, the same as posts above.
Thinks it is worth getting people to post their knowledge of dune, and only really remembers factions and sand worms. And femen wear suits and recycling units.Sandworm coult=jester.
Replys to nar, saying that if somone is scummy, then why not lynch,. Was responding to BN.
Says Paul atredis is the only real likely cult leader, and he used it to
attack the probably scum. So we probably don't have to worry about a
cult, as there is probably no cult. Or if there is a cult-"We don't have
to worry about it existence". That worries me a bit, but time to keep
Questions Mav on being eager to vote.
Says that getting two wins is going to be hard. If you know about faction
X, but not Y, you will have trouble. This means he is probably one of
those AA's, faction faction, and has one that he is a bit worried about.
Could be a townie one and a...less townie one that he isn't sure how to
acheive. Thats how I got in anyways. Conflicting factions would be scumy
and townie... First person to even suggest an AA set-up though.
Says that we aren't scumhunting. As has been brought up before, all he does is say it.
Would like to think he was good with flavor, but will probably need to
re-read. General factions ideas are liked, and agrees that cult is an
unlikely possibility. Would rather be safe that sorry however.
Agrees that we need to work more for factions than anything else-again, that only really works in a purely (A,B) set up, (although from spec there are A,A and A, B.)
Dr Ug is being silly with his game post, and then goes on about the
mass-claiming idea. Because some confirmed townies are obvious kill
targets, they don't want to be known. And factions mates may not be
pleased to know some of the peoples wins in their faction. Goes on to
talk about sandwerms, and says if there are any sandworms, probably not
safe to be near. Although the real reason claim thing, if krong were
cult, would be a way to distance the possibility. But I think he is town
Says sandworms may be mechanic-sandworm lynching unlikely.
Says the set-up seems pretty simple then. Town + masons(although nothing
confirmed the masons thing)and maybe atredis tratoir, and also mantions
how he thinks harkonnian were only scum because they weren't
protagonists. Somewhat scummy, but agrees with them being scum. Also
brings up second motivations.
Says that cult doesn't seem very likely flavor wise.Although may as well
assume that there might be, just to be safe.
Says rolespec is meant to generate discussion, and catch scumtells. If someone sees sometihng scummy, say so.
Says that we should still root for harkoneens, and even though we have other factions, should focus on faction goal.
Says that the language thing is interesting, Root for and root out.
Says roles go like this
You are X
Want this to happen
(Once again, (AB). Faction/independent. Not faction faction. Big nose was the first to bring (AA) up.)
Starts off with big bunches of rolespec as well. Agrees with
basics(Atredis=town, Harkonnian=scum) And gives some insight to otyher
things as well as a list of roles he thinks are possible, and what they
would be. Extrememly helpful to, say, rolecops.
weiyaoli: Says most flavor knowledge is from the wiki. So he isn't going
to be posting much content.
Another reason people may not want to roleclaim is because of lynchers.
Also, cult is what he thinkis is the likely possibility.
Gives joke post based off of the game. Early on, so that's alright. Says
he thought houses were just factions, but goes on to say that its
probably bad and good from mav's post are accurate.
Thinks all players are human.