PhoenixEnigma - Well, clearly, I'm town
Really, though, self analysis is rather useless for mafia imo.
ForAllOfThis - Argued pretty hard for what turned out to be a town lynch, and on what I'd consider pretty shaky evidence, but they were also very vocal about it. Either very bold scum or town, I think, and I'm leaning slightly towards town still.
and yeah, ninja'd a bit on the cjdrum thing.
Weeks - Has posted a lot - more than I have time to fully analyze while at work. Notice a mix of one-line type posts and longer ones, so the actual number of useful posts may be a little lower than it looks like at first glance. Lots of analysis and such tends to be either quite pro-town, or scum saying lots of obvious things and repeating others. Will need to go back and look over this later.
cjdrum - see above. Lurky, but that might be newbness, and in such a way I can't draw any conclusions. I'm deeply unhappy with the situation - I don't want to maybe give a free pass to scum, but I don't want to lynch without evidence, either. Wooy` has a point, though - claiming "don't look at me, I have a boring role" doesn't really come across very well.
Mavketl - Like Weeks, more posts than I can really analyze at work (as, you know, I kinda have to do actual work once in a while). Posts seem to average the same length as Weeks, maybe, but more consistent in length, dunno what that says. Another one to mark for a better look later.
VectorZero - See my earlier thoughts when voting for VZ. Haven't seen anything to change my mind, would consider to be on the scummy side of the scale. Same thing as FOAT, but without the same "redeeming" vocal and aggressive aspect. I'd like to hear a little more from them today, but very much IGMEOY.
Wooy` - Hasn't said a whole lot, most of what they have said seems fairly cautious, but reasonable. Nothing that really pings me specifically, although the late vote on wei, while explicitly noting that it could look scummy, could be a sort of wifom bandwagon deal. Not sure how far down that road I want to go, wine leads to madness (and occasional hangovers).
Chandani - Even more than than cjdrum, has been under my radar. They did kind of hop on the more_people bandwagon, but also mentioned in passing they have played on another forum where that's more typical. I'll buy that, but it also implies they're not very new to the game, which is something to keep in mind. Other than that, they do seem to be making at least a few posts outlining opinions and reasoning, and making some effort to drive discussion. The replacement thing is a little worrying, but I don't really see where all the hate is coming from.