There are no references to other named characters in my role pm.jimbobmacdoodle wrote:The bit of flavour that I interpreted to mean a possible second win con is directly tied to another character as well. I'd be interested to know if other players have similar pieces of info in their PMs, mainly because I wonder if there's some affect by interacting with the specific named characters, somehow (FTR, mine was not related to Red Vex). Of course, that could all be complete rubbish.
I do. At least I haven’t seen anything ruling it out.Carlington wrote:plytho - Wonders whether SirG was really the kill target from last night. Makes a good point about JDU's kill-counting power.Do you still believe this makes sense?plytho wrote:↶
Some explanation for my voting: I first voted for my top scum pick (Freezeblade), when I realized that it was going to be between Carlington and Znirk I tried to figure out which one was more scummy but I could not figure it out. At one point I felt the Carlington = SK theory made sense so I voted for him.
Carlington wrote:To elaborate on my claim - I did use a power last night, but I didn't necessarily gain any useful information from it. It is, however, possible that I was the reason there was only one kill last night and/or the reason plytho's power failed. I'm sure everyone playing can follow what I'm saying here. I do want to note that this soft claim doesn't cover my entire power.
I believe SK!Carlington could withhold their kill and make that claim in order to sow confusion. I’m not saying this has a high probability but I’m keeping it in mind.
I like your latest reads list more than the previous one. But it irks me a little that I pointed out a couple of things about your previous reads list:
plytho wrote:Carlington: This may be a bit of OMGUS but I still find it strange that he goes fromTo putting me as his top scum read after Znirkbob. The explanation that I’m one of 8 neutral reads and my slip got inflated doesn’t satisfy me if you say I stand out as town first. It also means that after the jimbob = survivor reveal nobody is particularly scummy according to Carlington. Hasn’t posted D3 I hope he noticed the lynch switched to Znirk in the end. Carlington, you’re alive!Carlington wrote:plytho stands out as town to me, despite that aforementioned slip. I'm inclined to believe it was an honest mistake, although I suppose that's subject to future information, as with all things.
@Carlington: do you find anybody scummy at this point?
And you start your next reads list with:
Carlington wrote:First things first: A couple of names have been eliminated from the list, leaving plytho right at the bottom. I'm really not happy with that situation though - no matter how neutral my read on everyone is, plytho is definitely not at the bottom of the pile.
It feels like your trying to show introspection while you were actually prodded.
I may be misunderstanding but is your strongest scumread jimbob at this point? Don't you agree he's a confirmed survivor due to Znirk's flip?Madge wrote:I really like laserguys post, and sabrars. Call me crazy but I don't think he's scum. I don't have any ideas who is though. If I die without a full claim it may be jimbob though.
If I'm counting correctly at this point there are 4 votes on sabrar (SDK, LaserGuy, GoP, Freezeblade).
Yeah, I'm really having trouble reading Sabrar. My gut says scum but I can't put my finger on it. I do think the secret lovers thing would be strange and the SDK=SK theory seems like a distraction.
Town to scum list
Gopher of Pern