I shall console myself that I got this correct when others doubted me:jimbobmacdoodle wrote:Some of us aren't surprised in the slightest...bessie wrote:I’m so annoyed at being so wrong about the setup. Or maybe I’m just annoyed because BoomFrog isn’t dying of love for me me me.
bessie wrote:What are you not understanding? I don’t think there’s an actual cult. I think wam may just be an ordinary roleblocker that leaves evidence that he has visited someone (by labeling them as Church of Moo). Many have theorized about weak powers, or negative aspects. I think this is just a clever variation of Loud.
Why somitomi, I didn’t realize you had such strong doubts about my setup spec. I know you were suspicious of my confidence in my better than average track record, but I wasn’t aware that you had decided on a two scum team setup. Perhaps it was because of your comment here?somitomi wrote:Did anyone say "told you so" yet?
Oh wait, Jimbob did, never mind.
somitomi wrote:Sabrar wrote:Why can't you reconcile it in a potential multiball setup?somitomi wrote:I'm struggling with the fact that SuicideJunkie is also quite suspicious to me and I'm not sure I can reconcile the two.
Well yes, but it's not surely multiball and I can get hung up on apparent inconsistencies within my reads.
So somitomi, a couple questions:
1. What exactly do you think the problem with my setup spec presented in this post (bessie’s detailed setup spec, not the backup guess), that made you sure it wasn’t the actual setup, sure enough to join in jimbob’s gloat?
2. When did you switch to thinking that the setup was likely multiball? There is no indication in the thread as to when you may have made this decision.
No one else answer.
I think it’s NAI.Sabrar wrote:I think bessie's attention to detail is townie.
Please clarify. Is it a tied vote between you and someone else, or between any two players? I can see you having a weak concern over the second option, but you should be familiar enough with this forum to know that a tie is almost never going to happen. If it is the first option, town!you should have been totally unconcerned because you would still need to tie with someone scummy, which meant that you were being scummy yourself.SuicideJunkie wrote:1) In the case of a tied vote, I get lynched. (Yep, Bessie. It could even be FIVE less votes required to lynch me early on, not just one or two, although admittedly town would try to avoid NLish things)
And why are you so concerned about living anyway? If you are town, it is not your job to survive to endgame. It is your job to catch scum in whatever way you can, and saving yourself by trying to look townie isn’t one of them. Did I already reference SDK in Meta Mafia? See this post.
Even if I give town!you #2 as your real disadvantage (which probably isn’t going to happen), #3 is so anti-town, I just can’t see it being given to a townie. I know, doesn't mean it can't happen. So let’s say you are telling the truth and were dealt a rather weak power and three very strong disadvantages. Why resign yourself so early on D1 to an unjust and certain easy demise? So what, town!you dies before D2, why let it ruin what could have been a spectacular D1?SuicideJunkie wrote: 3) My true actions are stealthed, so you'll only ever see me with dead people or idle, never doing innocent things.
Go ahead, make me look bad. I am totally completely unworried about it.jimbobmacdoodle wrote:For example, if we were to lynch town!SuicideJunkie we'd finally know what his role is and confirm his No Result. That could make bessie look bad, for example, because it might mean she's a rolestopper and is lying about getting a result on dimochka etc.
I was totally about to go on about a bessie-BoomFrog rolestopping vengeful sibling scum pair but I read ahead and saw this.jimbobmacdoodle wrote: The above suggested bessie-rolestopper (in contrast to a reflexive rolestopper) would fit that (cue bessie being unsurprised I bring this up), but I'm sure there are others.
I’m thinking about it. Agree with you that YinYang is a consideration.jimbobmacdoodle wrote: What is your guess about BoomFrog's buddy's power?
Because at least half this group is probably going to disappear over the weekend, I will claim that I targeted moody, and that my action would have no effect on wam’s action.