Player Analisis (Key points/opinions):LaserGuy
: First to post for the day, post contained simple comment. Switched d1 vote to JDU to prevent no-lynch based on Sabrar's suggestion. Comments on JDU being basically a cop with an extra ability to detect number of kills and wishes they had decided to play. Says the most simplest solution was Znirk sent the message himself and a false claim and ability to direct attention away from him is suspicious for someone who wins by staying out of the way. Explains characters determine roles and Znirks doesn't seem to match. Puts Madge in confirmed townies.
Putting Madge in confirmed town is a bit odd especially when he had another category of likely townies. All she has done is claimed miller, a townie move yes but not confirmed, he even said that her lurking feels a bit less townie but still placed her in the same category as those who have flipped town.Bessie
: Responds to LaserGuy's comment. Nothing to claim. Prods for Carlington to post. FOS everyone who buys jimbobs claim without question.
There hasn't been as much content from her for d2 but there is nothing scummy in her posts.Freezeblade
:FOS people who jumped on the lynch of JDU. Would like explanations from them. Thinks Sabrar is buddying with Znirk and votes for him. Describes how he dislikes d1 claims as a response to has he claimed indie in first post. Would have voted Znirk.
Has made a few posts d2 but has only provided a few opinions on Znirk, Sabrar and jimbob with no mention of anyone else. This lack of opinions or even mentioning other players is what I find most suspicious of his posts.plytho
:Votes d1 to counter Carlington's to give Znirk the chance to prove he isn't trying to get lynched. Picked JDU because either scum or no help to town. Argues against freezeblades suggestion that Sabrar was convincing people to vote JDU but then points out that Sabrar did decide to save Znirk. Worth looking at the wagon to find the 'at least one' scum. Interprets Znirks 'summary of the PM of saying jimbob is "likely town" as meaning jimbob is town rather than "not scum"(meaning indie) or that from Znirks characters perspective that it could be that he can't be identified and is "likely town". Nothing to report for night activities.
I find the accepting jimbob and Znirks claim for just the reads list a little odd. Instead of just leaving them off the reads list to look at later but accepting them as true is just weird.mpolo
: No information to claim. Suspected Sabrar end of d1 but not enough to vote. Seen nasty indies(SK) claim d1 so attention on Znirk is not misplaced.
:Confident there are hidden mechanics in the game. Thinks Znirk is Red Vex and Survivor is confirmed because he received a pm which says so. Says he feels bad about suggesting Znirk should switch votes. PM flavour suggests a conversation that convinced him that Red Vex was just looking to get out of town alive. Also confident that Znirk did not target him. @jimbob: you didn't answer my question of why you think this? Confirms both he and Znirk received the same PM. Claims to have targeted Znirk to redirect to Sabrar and believes himself roleblocked by the interaction. Votes LaserGuy for discussing easy stuff without needing to show thoughts on other players.
The PM jimbob received seems slightly suspicious. Just from what he said, the flavour he mention being "convinced" by a conversation
with a demon. Also jimbob seems to readily accept that the PM is truthful and Znirk is truthful without even looking at how it might not be. Both jimbob and Znirk seem to trust the PM a lot from how they interpret and explain it, but I don't know why since from what they say, I don't think I could. Sabrar
:Asks why d1 miller claim is more believable than indie. Thinks GoP might be jester, even night SK, LazerGuy role-fishing. Third on the wagon not necessarily scum rant. Suspects JDU's killing counter could have given a misleading result. Voted JDU not Znirk because they think Znirk is not a threat to town.
Over all Sabrars posts feel a lot less active lurky since d2, his post seem more neutral and more logical but I still feel his d1 content was a bit active lurky and his continuing argument of first day indie claim pings me a bit.Gopher of Pern
:Says likely more than 2 killing powers based on JDU's ability. Likes to see how people react to his words. Thinks Sabrar and plytho had least plausible reasons for voting JDU. Agrees LaserGuy seems scummier for pushing Znirk but FOS SirGabriel and Laser guy for harping on about it.
Gopher of Pern's has some good content in his first post and a few points in his others but he spent a lot of time arguing with Sabrar and created a lot of post that feel like togehter with Sabrar they are creating a distration. Madge
: short first d2 post. Comments that Sabrar's dedication is too weird to be a buddy. Thinks the Znirk/Jimbob conversation is suspicious but not a scum tell because of something in her role.
Still likely to be telling the truth with miller though the mention of something in her role has me curious. ahippo/SirGabriel
:No idea why ahippo claimed. Doesn't like how jimbob and freezeblade(posibly Madge) are so suspicious of everyone who voted JDU. Looks at posibilities of Znirks role. FOS on GoP for taking jimbobs claim for granted. Nothing to report for night activities.
Since SirG replaced it's hard to judge based on different play styles but SirG has seem to keep the same style of posts as he was for his last role which was town since his replacement. I had ahippo as neutral so overall I think I still finding them neutral or very marginally townie.Znirk
:Says he hopes dimochkas end-of-day comment isn't pointer to recruiter-scum. As survivor has to make use of any bandwagon. Claims tracking failed, possibly roleblocked. Doesn't want to say who he tracked early in the day. Thinks PM was triggered by secret role aspect. Agrees it doesn't seem possible that this is false information. Claims PM reveals jimbob is not scum. Claims flavour in role PM: Red Vex made demonic pact to return for revenge but target was already dead. Reveals Sabrar was his tracking target with his opinion LaserGuy and Sabrar could be scum together.
Of course Znirk wouldn't say the PM is false information since it was what he had claimed, if it hadn't matched then he would be claiming there was no way it could be true. Since it did match what he claimed it would only have been able to be cause by Znirk, caused by jimbob(only if Znirk is telling the truth) or someone trying to make people think Znirk is telling the truth. I think he is definitely anti town.Carlington
: Nothing to claim from last night, doesn't plan on lurking. Voted Znirk because his claim was the scummiest thing that stood out.
Although claiming to lurk less there has still been very little from him d2. His rushed posts at the end of d1 provided quite a bit of content that I didn't find scummy so he is currently only still on the slightly scummy side of neutral.
Gopher of Pern