LaserGuy wrote:For D1: I have a posting restriction called "chatterbox".
Fine, let's look at those reads:
LaserGuy: Spends most of his time talking about the setup and vote abilities, with no opinions on individual players so far, apart from his comment about SDK and his early claim of town!bessie. I'm really confused by his "Unvote Znirk" when he was voting for SDK at the time, but I assume he meant "Vote Znirk", in which case, I want to know why he meant that, given that his only comment was on Znirk's (presumed) mistake saying that SDK said that Madge is town, which was fairly clearly meant to be about bessie. As stated previously, I found his question asking me if I had reason to believe other than a two-scum team to be role-fishing. If I had information to share that I thought would be valuable to share at this point, I'd have shared it. Scummy, and this time not because of lack of posts.
This was posted a third of the way through page 4. My most recent post from there was two days earlier at the top of page 3. At that point in the discussion everyone was still talking about setup, SDK/bessie, and voting powers. I'm not sure why he thought my question was rolefishing. He asked why I thought there were two scumteams; I asked him why he thought there was one + SK.
LaserGuy - (14th, scummy): I've already made comments about LaserGuy and how I don't like a lot of what he's said up to now. The thing that's bothering me the most is his accusations against SDK. He really isn't trying very hard to think of why town!SDK might confirm bessie as town. That all being said, a number of his opinions do match my own, and his response to SDK's recent question feels like it would have been hard to manufacture as scum. I still think he is scum, but I'm not 100% confident in it. Possibly an anti-town indie?
My accusations against SDK were well-founded. Yes, there might have been the odd townie role that might have had a townie reason to reveal this, but there's very few that fit. Even the ones mentioned like Guardian Angel, etc. don't make sense to be revealing their target like SDK did. I feel like a lot of people were looking for low-probability explanations for what SDK was doing here, rather than the most likely, straightforward, and, as it turns out, correct one: SDK wanted to kill bessie.
LaserGuy - He's talked about basically nothing other than me - and came down on the wrong side of the fence for the wrong reasons there.
At this point in the thread, I had posted twice more than in jimbob1. One
of those posts was answering questions directed at me. In the second
, I'm answering questions, explaining my unvote on Znirk, and posted a full reads list for good measure. The first part of SDK's comment here is actually kind of weird, since in the first of the aforementioned posts, I'm responding to a point by bessie where she said that I hadn't talked about SDK at all except to say that I shared suspicions of him with Gopher.
jimbobmacdoodle as an Officer - Same feeling as previous game: focused on things I see as secondary, noncommittal on things that matter. Scum lean.
LaserGuy as the King of France - Same feeling as jimbobmacdoodle.
jimbob is town.
Doesn't say why he's reading me that way so it's hard to comment. On page 3 he said this, FWIW:
LaserGuy as the King of France - Enthusiastic examination of excrement is still the work of scum.
A common theme in all of these comments is the amount of time I spent talking about setup, SDK/bessie, voting powers, etc., which, yeah, I did. I didn't have a huge number of posts when a lot of these were written, but they were big posts where I expounded on all of these topics at length. As I said, this was deliberate, and a result of my posting restriction. Take that all away, and what's left in these comments that's concerning to you?
LaserGuy wrote:What do you think of YOLO's explanations and his roleclaim?
Okay, so now I'm kind of getting suspicious that you're just setting me up. I especially like how you deliberately hid the context to make it look scummier. Here's the relevant context:
DGames | Bard wrote:I really want Yoloswag to come clean and explain himself a bit more, as well as answer my earlier question.
What do you think of YOLO's explanations and his roleclaim?
The quote from Bard is posted here
. I'm responding to Bard here
. In the intervening period, YOLO fullclaimed. So I wanted to know what he thought of YOLO's claim. Bard basically hadn't talked about any other player besides Gopher at this point, so I wanted to draw him out and find out what his opinions were.
LaserGuy wrote:Which scumteam do you think YOLO is on?
No context again. You didn't even include the full quotation this time. Here's what was actually said:
DGames | Bard wrote:@Laserguy - My King! I'm not really a fan of Sir Yoloswag's play style; I can't say I get his suspicions of me this game because he hasn't really explained them to me. He kinda asserts himself in a way that isn't very transparent with his intentions, i.e. he says my posts are "disgusting," but he doesn't say what is "disgusting" about them. Another example that comes to mind is when he says I should be in the lynch pool, but doesn't really go in depth with the why. I'm not sure how he expects me to trust him in this type of situation. On that note, I wonder how he feels about me going for Gopher as a priority before putting him further on the chopping block.
Who in your mind do you see as probable scummates for YOLO? What about Gopher?
Hey, Bard has opinions on two people now! Let's see if I can get him to talk about somebody else. (He doesn't
). I'm really curious as to why you would read these questions as defending YOLO, rather than trying to engage Bard. I'm also curious as to why you didn't bother to include the relevant context into these questions.
LaserGuy wrote:Which scumteam do you think YOLO is on?
LaserGuy wrote:And why do you think the roleblocker would be on the same team as the person with roleblock immunity?
The second question was the one that I was interested in. But it was moot if you believed that he was on the supernatural team, so I asked about that first. BoomFrog had already posted that he thought YOLO was Guild, so I figured I'd get both of you to respond at once.
Speaking of which, how about we follow up on this? In response to the first question, you said that YOLO being Guild was just a hunch
. Which is fine. When I proposed the second question, your response was this
Sabrar wrote:1. Because there are duplicate roles.
2. Because YOLOSWAG is lying about being RB.
Take your pick.
What about 3. YOLO is supernatural? You said it was "just a hunch" that he was Guild five posts earlier. What changed in the intervening period that made you so certain he was Guild?