bessie- some early analysis, slightly suspicious of Madge, will be upset if BoomFrog is obfuscating as scum, little bit of indignation over me and LG's reactions to BF's oracular accusation,
My objection is not to the content in the confirmation posts. It’s the attitude that confirmation posts don’t count as game content. Conformation posts most certainly count as game content. Anything posted in the game thread counts as game content and is fair game to be analyzed
This looks like you are getting your wish about SDK's techniques. speculation of reasons given in response to Madge look weighted on her being antagonistic, some responses to Sabrar, pleased with Mark, analysis of Vicarin resulting in a vote, no Red Ajah. mostly standard bessie, but seemed a little defensive me and LG were agreeing with BF calling her scum. slightly townie
BoomFrog- the Oracle, 2nd win difficult and might be anti town, says bessie is scum, then later switches to saying she's town (btw, this is what I expect a planned reaction trap to look like), accuses Sabrar of role-fishing, looks like he thinks mpolo is town. town
heury- rv Madge, speculates boring 8-3 setup, setup spec is townie behavior, likes conditions for more content, unvotes, bessie and BF as town.
Well if mafia has day chat, I don't think Boomfrog and moody are scum buddies.
Kind of weird thing to assume given there has been less than a quarter of games have had this (don't have the numbers immediately at hand), volunteers to get a "present" from Madge. town
LaserGuy- votes bessie based on her reaction to BF, says to ignore Sabrar's power comment, heury and mpolo townie, also Mark, with a small expansion on his heury read when prompted by Sabrar, simultaneously rationalizing and doubling-down on bessie vote, pokes Madge on her Sabrar vote, Sabrar too reserved, switches vote to Madge (unofficially, since he didn't unvote). slightly scummy
Madge- unambiguous "bessie's town", votes Sabrar, no value in setup spec, hedges wrt bessie, has something to do with her and Sabrar's reads being entangled, offers a present. She's doing a good job as SDK, because I don't know what's going on with her.
Mark- tries to decode the oracle, some rules confusion, some role and setup spec, response to Vicarin about bessie reads her as town, response to bessie re BF being the oracle, foses wam over lack of content. slightly townie
mpolo- suspects he might be a miller, 2nd win difficult, setup spec with more than one anti-town, likes Mark's content, in character hypothesis for BF being oracular, spec on the pick your Ajah nature, which is refuted by bessie and also refutes his hypothesis. slightly townie for now, but that miller thing might be something to keep an eye on late game.
Sabrar- invites targeting for 2nd win condition, says not PGO
, some setup spec, rv LaserGuy, points Mark to bessie getting his point, unvotes, pokes LG on his town reads, decides anyone who didn't pick up on his math error is maybe scum, compliments Madge on SDK-play, short reads of people, votes Vicarin, calls LG town for his Madge vote. not getting a strong read on him.
Vicarin- flavor blind, and unsure on possible setup spec. rv Madge, balance issues with the 7 and singles setup, several questions, switches vote to BF for being oracular (which is a very petty reason). doesn't like wam's only post, returns to setup spec, seems very eager over his 2nd win condition, newer player may not read over rules as well, scum more picky, basically doesn't buy everyone's town!Mark read. My hypothesis is his secondary win is as a lyncher, and he's trying to find out if it's pro- or anti- town by getting a good read on his target. Otherwise I'm feeling a little uncomfortable with Vicarin; slightly scummy
wam- first post says he's okay with other people's setup spec, upset by people taking advantage of previously mentioned away time. insufficient data.