moody7277 – I should have played D1 as your meta but I thought about it too late. Too bad I could have saved plytho from the lynch.
plytho – It’s just not a game unless I get to tunnel on you.
But yes, I think we could have worked everything out if we had another half hour.
jimbobmacdoodle – Hmm, I’m concerned that you and I are never going to work things out. We’re always in conflict, unless we’re scum together then we’re best buds in the world.
wam – I knew knew knew it from your confirmation post. Why didn’t you plan for me replacing? I was on the replacement list.
somitomi – Thanks for subbing in, I know you were trying to skip D1 and all, and I felt kinda bad that I wasn’t available earlier to take the mafia spot instead of you.
somitomi wrote:Of course bessie saw through me the moment she entered the game...
It wasn't you, I had already narrowed in on wam. Sorry for never really giving you a chance to convince me otherwise, but I’m secretly pleased you fell for my claiming gambit.
Mark_Cangila – You really played an amazing game, you picked the right targets, and your claims created just the right kind of confusion to enable town to win.
LaserGuy – Not sure why you think this:
LaserGuy wrote:I feel like we were kind of working in different directions this game
Hmm, I sorta feel the opposite. I “knew” it was you that sent me the cop result. Was it BoomFrog or someone else that said somewhere (Gojoe?) that I should have pretended the cop result was mine and tried to draw the NK, I totally would have done that but my little puppy brain didn’t think of it in time.
mpolo – Interesting, one of the reasons I targeted you N1 was that I thought no one else would (I thought everything was going to hit Zen and BoomFrog because, well, they are Is Zen and Is BoomFrog). Oops, it seems my secret fear of your considerable abilities has spread to others. Now if I could only get everyone to heed my warnings about the dangers of Madge. . .
Vicarin – You and I have a way to go before we find our understanding, but we’ll eventually get there. It took me and LaserGuy, hmmm, about a year and a half.
Zenii – Your remarkable content drew me in as I struggled to make it through my difficulties replacing on D1, and inspired me to do my best. I don’t always understand the magic of Zen, but that’s how it should be.
BoomDog – You will always be my woof. Unfortunately, you’ll also always be my woof woof. Perhaps, like Zen said, you can indeed read minds, but you don’t need to read my mind to know how I feel about playing with you, it’s written all over this forum. <3
Special thanks to Madge, the master of writing entertaining flavor quickly, and to Sabrar, the master of entertaining game design.
Some game notes.
I'd also put the Sash win con in the role PM itself to stop any confusion. Can't believe I didn't think of "my precious" type flavour for the Sash as Bessie intimated there should have been. Maybe next year!
I think perhaps your mistake was that you thought the motivation for players would be obvious because of your familiarity with the TV show (guessing here because I’m flavor blind). I could see no motivation to actively try to posses the sash from the flavor in the thread or that I received privately.
BoomFrog wrote: Men [and labrador retrievers] cannot fathom the greed of dwarves [and corgis].
Sabrar wrote:Let's look at the Sash-related win-con in more detail. It states that you need to possess the Sash at the end of the game.
This probably should have been explicit for all players, not implied. Because there was no clearly defined sash win con, and no explicit flavor motivation to do so, I deduced that it must be part of the non-town win condition. The assumption for town is that the town win condition is the primary goal, anything else should be a bonus.