Sorry, when I made this post I thought I saw you online so I decided to ping you. When you didn’t answer I thought you were ignoring me.somitomi wrote:Um, I would be okay with such a "reminder" if I had posted anything since you disapproved of my reply. But I didn't, I wasn't even away for that long, yet you have impatiently demanded an asnwer not once, but twice. What gives?
Town!you had no reason not consider my setup spec as a possibility. Based on publicly available information on D2, there was nothing that made my setup spec automatically invalid. True, no one else was completely behind my guess, but no one had outright dismissed it except Vicarin (on D1) and jimbobmacdoodle.somitomi wrote:bessie wrote:You didn’t answer the question. What element(s) was so ridiculous in my setup spec that made you certain I was incorrect? What, in your opinion, made my setup spec invalid?
Again, it wasn't the setup spec itself or any element of it (although that BoomFrog lover thing was a bit out there), but the amount of information it was based on. Yeah, semantically that might not be an answer to your question, but I think you're being unreasonable at this point.
Anyway, I was typing this up to get my thoughts together, and trying to figure out if you did indeed have a reason you knew my setup spec wasn’t correct, because your responses to me have felt so off. Your odd here, when you had given no indication on D2 that you believed me to be wrong. Your inability (or unwillingness) to answer a direct question from me to point to what you found wrong with my setup spec in this post. And in your latest post all you have to say is that the BoomFrog thing is “out there” before you throw it back on me for being “unreasonable”. The lover idea was not “out there” it was a reasonable guess for a third “half mafia” role. Day vig is not unreasonable, with mafia only having one other kill. What is it that you want so badly to discredit about my setup spec?
My D2 Setup guess was 8-3, detailed here (underlining added).
bessie wrote: bessie's detailed setup spec:
Apps of Destruction
Abilities: Day chat, factional one-shot night kill, cops as “something non human” to investigations.
App #1 Vicarin: Vote Thief
App #2 SuicideJunkie: Unblockable one-shot day kill
App #3 BoomFrog: Unrequited lover of bessie*
. . .
the Church of Moo is the McGuffin.
somitomi, if someone were to investigate your species, do you have any reason to believe you would not appear as human?
Same question to jimbobmacdoodle, but only after somitomi answers.
Why would you care about proving either? I don’t think that’s a townie mindset. See this post, you can skim it for your name.somitomi wrote:bessie wrote:somitomi, in regards to this post I made on D1, which is it, BoomFrog or Vicarin?
Neither. Moody has done a nice job explaining why I'm not BoomFrog's buddy and I don't see any way to prove I'm not Vicarin's mate.