_infina_ wrote:I quite honestly believe BN is scum. Once Mephisto and Diablo are lynched, it is as if there are no power roles on either side, and the GF will be just another goon that we must sniff out as if in a completely vanilla game. Baal's only power is to hide from the cop, but other mafia could hide among us just the same as Baal if there were no cop. The way he is posting, trying to worry us about the GF, causes me to think he is either Mephisto or Diablo. My vote stands, as it will unless someone more scummy appears with a chance for hammering.
But there IS a cop and while we have him around, scum have to push for Townie lynchings and hopefully take other Townies along too. This is why a no-lynch day is BAD for Townies. On Day 2, assuming we haven't lynched the GF, we can then look over the lynching and NK data and hope there is some sort of reveal there, or ditto Day 3. While the GF is around, the Cop can't trust his 'copping' of a Townie.
So while your personal opinion of me is scum, my personal opinion is that I would like to see the GF dead first.
_infina_ wrote:Unless he is the cop. It makes perfect sense for jayhsu to be either cop or mafia, so we should wait and see there.
I agree, which is why I haven't voted.
ElectricHaze wrote:I can believe BN is scum. He seems a little off, but I'm not sure why. Maybe I just don't like the way he presents his analysis.
Which bit of analysis are you referring to?
keeneal wrote:A vanilla townie claim on D1 really ought to set off big red alarms on your scumdar. Either he's trying to hint at being the cop/spy or he's slipped up big time. He's a decent player... if he wanted to leave hints he could do it better than that. It wasn't a rookie mistake. Either he's sending a message or he slipped up. I think he slipped up.
Most of this I agree with. He is a good player and I think that he wouldn't make a mistake as big as this:
jayhsu wrote:I guess I feel bad for the cop in this game.
This on its own may have been a little scummish.
jayhsu wrote:They've really got their work cut out for them...
He now backs that up, making it stand out.
jayhsu wrote:My job as vanilla adventurer is relatively easy by comparison.
And finally, seems to paint a giant target on his back.
The cop wouldn't do it (unless they were very ballsy).
Scum wouldn't do it (unless they were very ballsy).
So the only other option is a Townie.
Hence, I will continue to refrain voting for him (despite calls for it otherwise) for now.