Woah, 2 role claims already. Doubt both are false because that would be way too risky. Possible that one is false - the fact that captfinglass conveniently neglected to tell us her name, only to be appended by a rather brisk reply later on prods me into believing it's a desperate claim... still, it could just as likely to be a desperate town claim. Not going to take my chances and a no lynch probably isn't good for us either. anyways...Looks like my head's about to roll - I don't like giving more info as I feel like too much has been given already and it really doesn't do town any favours.
[quote=UniqueScreenname]My thought was that in wanting everyone to assume that cops were sane, then you wanted there to remain some doubt in the validity of cop results if you were exposed. [/quote]
Huh? Honestly that was not my train of thought at all... why would I be worried about an expose when I'm town?
but I'm still quite concerned about the willingness to lynch a townie. And sure, it's speculation, but that's kinda what you're supposed to do in this game. It's not like there's a whole bunch of absolute truth to go on.
Carey isn't a confirmed town. There is nothing to say he isn't a scum playing the newbie card. He hasn't said anything at all today and hasn't really provided much content or analysis other than ones based on hysteria - He vote switched so many times that it's become difficult to read him. I get that we should give him a chance since he's a newb and everything, but let's not ignore all the obvious scum-tells just because he's a newb.
This is not what I was getting at. I was saying we can't assume that the cops are limited to her. Earlier I had said we don't know if Eliza is here or if there are more cops than her. So if someone came out and said they were a cop, but it wasn't her, there would be doubt. I honestly agree that a cop in the show would be sane in the game, but any others I would worry about. Fearless responded that she thinks it's unlikely there's more than one cop. To me that could pass as an honest opinion, and if I had no other concerns about her I would have unvoted.
Ok so I think we've established that this game isnt likely to have more than one cop. Now, with that in mind, why would the cop role NOT be Eliza, who's a main character on the show? why would the cop role be, say for example, a random person that we know nothing about...? Doesn't make sense?
I feel like youre simply trying to force us into an insanity bubble, possibly hoping that we'd either waste an investigation or spend too much time obsessing over our sanity or simply spread lots of wine. Vote unique screen name
Because I'm not going to chance voting those who role claimed