1087: "Cirith Ungol"

This forum is for the individual discussion thread that goes with each new comic.

Moderators: Moderators General, Prelates, Magistrates

vortighast
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 25, 2011 4:41 am UTC

1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby vortighast » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:09 am UTC

Image

Title-Text: "My all-time favorite example of syntactic ambiguity comes from Wikipedia: "Charlotte's Web is a children's novel by American author E. B. White, about a pig named Wilbur who is saved from being slaughtered by an intelligent spider named Charlotte."

Must be a VERY intelligent spider to slaughter a pig...

User avatar
rhomboidal
Posts: 796
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2011 5:25 pm UTC
Contact:

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby rhomboidal » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:10 am UTC

Further along, Frodo finds that Charlotte has "web"-logged about how Wilbur was the best pig she ever had.

Draco18s
Posts: 87
Joined: Fri Oct 03, 2008 7:50 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Draco18s » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:12 am UTC

Took me a while to understand the alt text:

Wilbur who is saved from being (slaughtered by an intelligent spider named Charlotte).
Wilbur who is saved (from being slaughtered) by an intelligent spider named Charlotte.

Tirian
Posts: 1891
Joined: Fri Feb 15, 2008 6:03 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Tirian » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:15 am UTC

Thank you. I thought he was trying to parse that it was E.B. White who was saved from slaughter.

vortighast
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 25, 2011 4:41 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby vortighast » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:17 am UTC

Interesting, the current article for Charlotte's Web has that exact sentence, except moved "by an intelligent spider" to before "from being slaughtered." I wonder if Randall did that...

Draco18s
Posts: 87
Joined: Fri Oct 03, 2008 7:50 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Draco18s » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:20 am UTC

vortighast wrote:I wonder if Randall did that...


Nope. ZombieRamen did. Change note indicates it was done to "remove ambiguity as to who is doing the slaughtering"

User avatar
whateveries
Posts: 128
Joined: Thu Feb 10, 2011 2:14 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby whateveries » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:21 am UTC

obviously charlotte rolled well on the bite crit table.
it's fine.

User avatar
Quicksilver
Posts: 437
Joined: Wed Apr 29, 2009 6:21 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Quicksilver » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:32 am UTC

A panda eats, shoots and leaves?

User avatar
Jorpho
Posts: 6276
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 5:31 am UTC
Location: Canada

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Jorpho » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:39 am UTC

Seven comments in, and I see no one cares to explain what Cirith Ungol is.

Yes, the alt-text is funny, and the art is kinda nice, I guess, but otherwise this is flying way over my head.

User avatar
Number3Pencils
The Torment of Existence Weighed against the Horror of Nonbeing
Posts: 516
Joined: Sat Sep 01, 2007 6:27 am UTC
Location: Beyond reason, then take a left
Contact:

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Number3Pencils » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:46 am UTC

I didn't know Cirith Ungol either, so I looked it up. Turns out it's the name of the place where the giant spider Shelob lived in The Lord of the Rings. So there you go.
Image
Spoiler:
Image

User avatar
Djehutynakht
Posts: 1546
Joined: Thu Feb 10, 2011 1:37 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Djehutynakht » Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:59 am UTC

Most of this is lost on me this time (I'm not even quite getting the syntactic ambiguity despite the explanation), but I do like the artwork.

So there you go.

scottgoblue314
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri Oct 23, 2009 10:47 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby scottgoblue314 » Fri Jul 27, 2012 5:00 am UTC

Jorpho wrote:Seven comments in, and I see no one cares to explain what Cirith Ungol is.

Yes, the alt-text is funny, and the art is kinda nice, I guess, but otherwise this is flying way over my head.


I was going to give you a hard time about not having the nerd-cred to know a LotR reference, but then I remembered this comic: http://xkcd.com/1053/

So go read your Tolkien! It's wonderful.

User avatar
Bartimaeus
Posts: 111
Joined: Tue Oct 14, 2008 3:35 pm UTC
Location: Somewhere near NYC, but nobody's heard of

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Bartimaeus » Fri Jul 27, 2012 5:07 am UTC

Technically it isn't where Shelob lurks(it's the nearby watchtower), but close enough I suppose. I'm just happy for a LoTR reference! At first, I actually thought that the comic was the drawing, rather than a joke(I didn't see the writing on the web). Funny punchline as well, though, when I saw the alt-text. A+

tetromino
Posts: 114
Joined: Wed May 02, 2007 11:31 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby tetromino » Fri Jul 27, 2012 5:09 am UTC

Jorpho wrote:Seven comments in, and I see no one cares to explain what Cirith Ungol is.

In Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings, Cirith Ungol is a little-used mountain pass leading from the Morgul Vale into Mordor.
Spoiler:
The pass is little-used because it's guarded by a giant spider called Shelob. Gollum leads Frodo and Samwise via Cirith Ungol, hoping that the nasty hobbitses would get eaten by the spider so that he would be able to loot the One Ring from Frodo's remains.
Also, obligatory Wikipedia link.

User avatar
Jorpho
Posts: 6276
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 5:31 am UTC
Location: Canada

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Jorpho » Fri Jul 27, 2012 5:17 am UTC

Ahh, but the first Google hit (and several of the images that turn up) are for a metal band.

This comic is of course the tenth hit at the moment and will only rise further.

User avatar
ysth
Posts: 183
Joined: Wed Apr 11, 2007 7:21 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby ysth » Fri Jul 27, 2012 5:55 am UTC

I'm not surprised. You can't expect a writer of mere kids books to be an expert on writing style, right?
A math joke: r = | |csc(θ)|+|sec(θ)| |-| |csc(θ)|-|sec(θ)| |

CleverDick
Posts: 19
Joined: Sat Jun 30, 2012 10:06 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby CleverDick » Fri Jul 27, 2012 5:59 am UTC

I actually read the alt text and thought "Wait, that's Charlotte's Web? I thought that was a kid's book."
But a novel about a sinister spider setting out to slaughter a sow sounds sensational.

Eutychus
Posts: 446
Joined: Mon Jan 25, 2010 6:01 am UTC
Location: France

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Eutychus » Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:02 am UTC

I'm not convinced that Shelob would be writing on her web in English.

Still less convinced that Frodo would be able to read it.

(Major bad moment in LOTR movies: the party notice on Bilbo's gate being written in English).
Be very careful about rectilinear assumptions. Raptors could be hiding there - ucim

Simplex
Posts: 33
Joined: Wed Aug 27, 2008 6:08 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Simplex » Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:24 am UTC

Reminds me of something i stumbled across recently...

Image

Ardee
Posts: 13
Joined: Fri Apr 29, 2011 6:28 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Ardee » Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:25 am UTC

I *really* want to post a great Wikipedia ambiguity, but if I do, it'll get fixed, which would make the world a lesser place. So I'll just sit here and let you imagine what a terrific joke you're missing.

RJFerret
Posts: 10
Joined: Wed Nov 19, 2008 7:31 pm UTC
Contact:

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby RJFerret » Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:30 am UTC

Eutychus wrote:(Major bad moment in LOTR movies: the party notice on Bilbo's gate being written in English).

Why wouldn't it be, since the books are presented as "translated" from common speech. It certainly wouldn't have been in Sindarin or Quenya or the Black Speech. Tolkien didn't even develop Westron (common speech) as a language like he did the others (and didn't publish some works of it during his life apparently).

It makes more sense to me to present the translation, rather than fabricate something false.

mfc
Posts: 14
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2009 9:25 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby mfc » Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:53 am UTC

It would have been nice if the skull in the comic were a pig's skull ... :-)

TheoGB
Posts: 70
Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2008 1:38 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby TheoGB » Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:58 am UTC

Eutychus wrote:I'm not convinced that Shelob would be writing on her web in English.

Still less convinced that Frodo would be able to read it.

(Major bad moment in LOTR movies: the party notice on Bilbo's gate being written in English).


To be poindexter-like in accuracy, that would be Sam not Frodo. And there's even less chance he could read it.

TheoGB
Posts: 70
Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2008 1:38 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby TheoGB » Fri Jul 27, 2012 7:01 am UTC

Ardee wrote:I *really* want to post a great Wikipedia ambiguity, but if I do, it'll get fixed, which would make the world a lesser place. So I'll just sit here and let you imagine what a terrific joke you're missing.


I *still* want to know what Gaiman is referring to here: http://journal.neilgaiman.com/2010/05/o ... ering.html

sotanaht
Posts: 236
Joined: Sat Nov 27, 2010 2:14 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby sotanaht » Fri Jul 27, 2012 7:46 am UTC

Quicksilver wrote:A panda eats, shoots and leaves?


That's not ambiguous at all in text form since we can see the comma or lack thereof.

User avatar
Oflick
Posts: 138
Joined: Thu Jul 24, 2008 2:27 am UTC
Location: Sydney, California, France

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Oflick » Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:11 am UTC

Another case of the alt-text being better than the comic.

My favourite piece of poor wording on Wikipedia was changed a few months ago (I stalked the page for a while hoping no one would pick it up). From the article on Karen Carpenter (6 January 2012):

Her death was attributed to heart failure, from complications related to her illness, which caused her to believe mistakenly that she needed to lose weight.

pff
Posts: 1
Joined: Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:21 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby pff » Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:31 am UTC

So... the ambiguity of the wiki entry makes you think that the spider slaughtered the pig, which the art is about (see the text in the web)?

Arariel
Posts: 404
Joined: Fri Sep 17, 2010 2:32 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Arariel » Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:57 am UTC

sotanaht wrote:
Quicksilver wrote:A panda eats, shoots and leaves?


That's not ambiguous at all in text form since we can see the comma or lack thereof.

We invited the strippers, JFK and Stalin?

(Oxford comma ftw)

User avatar
Qaanol
The Cheshirest Catamount
Posts: 3069
Joined: Sat May 09, 2009 11:55 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Qaanol » Fri Jul 27, 2012 9:32 am UTC

One of my favorite Wiki-wordings is from the article Mast (botany), which contains the sentence, “It has been traditional to turn pigs into forests to fatten on this form of mast.” In this case the ambiguity is semantic rather than syntactic, but nonetheless it gives rise to a strange mental image.
wee free kings

Dave
Posts: 59
Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2007 4:26 pm UTC
Location: London. Londinium.

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Dave » Fri Jul 27, 2012 10:07 am UTC

Am I failing to 'get' the drawing because I've not read Charlotte's web?

I kinda get the title text. And I get that Cirith Ungol is a LOTR reference to Shelob. I'm just not sure why 'Some Pig' on a web is funny, but I suspect that's due to the above. :?

LordHorst
Posts: 45
Joined: Fri Oct 22, 2010 6:17 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby LordHorst » Fri Jul 27, 2012 10:31 am UTC

Dave wrote:Am I failing to 'get' the drawing because I've not read Charlotte's web?


No.

The drawing pictures Frodo (or was ist Sam?) inside Cirith Ungol. Complete with the one Ring and the veil he got from the elves.

Wlerin
Posts: 28
Joined: Fri Aug 14, 2009 8:16 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Wlerin » Fri Jul 27, 2012 11:04 am UTC

LordHorst wrote:
Dave wrote:Am I failing to 'get' the drawing because I've not read Charlotte's web?


No.

The drawing pictures Frodo (or was ist Sam?) inside Cirith Ungol. Complete with the one Ring and the veil he got from the elves.

*Yes.

"Some pig" is from Charlotte's Web,
Spoiler:
one of the phrases she wrote on her web to generate publicity for Wilbur, which in turn made him too famous to slaughter.
The comic combines the two, presumably on the inspiration of the ambiguity in the alt-text.

Also, it's a phial.

LordHorst
Posts: 45
Joined: Fri Oct 22, 2010 6:17 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby LordHorst » Fri Jul 27, 2012 11:09 am UTC

Wlerin wrote:
LordHorst wrote:
Dave wrote:Am I failing to 'get' the drawing because I've not read Charlotte's web?


No.

The drawing pictures Frodo (or was ist Sam?) inside Cirith Ungol. Complete with the one Ring and the veil he got from the elves.

*Yes.

"Some pig" is from Charlotte's Web,


Thanks for enlightening me.

Also, it's a phial.


Oh boy. Better I quickly add that meaning to Veil to cover up my horrendous mistake... :|

User avatar
SerMufasa
Posts: 159
Joined: Fri Feb 17, 2012 2:00 pm UTC
Location: Casterley Rock

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby SerMufasa » Fri Jul 27, 2012 11:23 am UTC

How to add an extra layer of humor to the comic:

Imagine that Gollum impelled Shelob to write the comment, and notice that Sam is absent.
"Winter is Coming, Simba"

Schiffy
Posts: 1
Joined: Fri Jul 27, 2012 11:57 am UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Schiffy » Fri Jul 27, 2012 12:00 pm UTC

Randall must be pretty popular if the text on the actual Charlotte's Web article was changed the same day the comic was posted.

http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Charlotte%27s_Web&action=history

User avatar
The Moomin
Posts: 358
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2010 6:59 am UTC
Location: Yorkshire

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby The Moomin » Fri Jul 27, 2012 12:01 pm UTC

Qaanol wrote:One of my favorite Wiki-wordings is from the article Mast (botany), which contains the sentence, “It has been traditional to turn pigs into forests to fatten on this form of mast.” In this case the ambiguity is semantic rather than syntactic, but nonetheless it gives rise to a strange mental image.


Pig iron exists. It makes sense that before developing pig iron, they would have had a pig wood based culture.
I'm alive because the cats are alive.
The cats are alive because I'm alive.
Specious.

rmsgrey
Posts: 3616
Joined: Wed Nov 16, 2011 6:35 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby rmsgrey » Fri Jul 27, 2012 12:05 pm UTC

TheoGB wrote:
Eutychus wrote:I'm not convinced that Shelob would be writing on her web in English.

Still less convinced that Frodo would be able to read it.

(Major bad moment in LOTR movies: the party notice on Bilbo's gate being written in English).


To be poindexter-like in accuracy, that would be Sam not Frodo. And there's even less chance he could read it.


It would be Frodo who bore the ring and Galadriel's Phial through Shelob's Lair - the events that led to Sam taking the ring took place after they'd emerged from the tunnel on the far side.

I loosely translate Cirith Ungol as "Spider Pass" (Cirith is a cleft, crack or chasm, and Ungol, I assume, is related to Ungoliant, the spider-demon who spawned the race of which Shelob was the last known survivor, and who helped Morgoth steal the Silmarils and blighted the Trees of Valinor in the days before the dawning of the First Age of the Sun)

User avatar
SerMufasa
Posts: 159
Joined: Fri Feb 17, 2012 2:00 pm UTC
Location: Casterley Rock

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby SerMufasa » Fri Jul 27, 2012 12:06 pm UTC

The Moomin wrote:
Qaanol wrote:One of my favorite Wiki-wordings is from the article Mast (botany), which contains the sentence, “It has been traditional to turn pigs into forests to fatten on this form of mast.” In this case the ambiguity is semantic rather than syntactic, but nonetheless it gives rise to a strange mental image.


Pig iron exists. It makes sense that before developing pig iron, they would have had a pig wood based culture.


+1
"Winter is Coming, Simba"

blowfishhootie
Posts: 486
Joined: Wed Sep 21, 2011 11:13 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby blowfishhootie » Fri Jul 27, 2012 12:13 pm UTC

scottgoblue314 wrote:
Jorpho wrote:Seven comments in, and I see no one cares to explain what Cirith Ungol is.

Yes, the alt-text is funny, and the art is kinda nice, I guess, but otherwise this is flying way over my head.


I was going to give you a hard time about not having the nerd-cred to know a LotR reference, but then I remembered this comic: http://xkcd.com/1053/

So go read your Tolkien! It's wonderful.


You should mock Jorpho not for not knowing what Cirith Ungol is, but for taking the time to type the question here but not putting it into Google where (s)he could have answered the question pretty easily.

Situations like this are why the Web site Let Me Google That For You exist.

Wlerin
Posts: 28
Joined: Fri Aug 14, 2009 8:16 pm UTC

Re: 1087: "Cirith Ungol"

Postby Wlerin » Fri Jul 27, 2012 12:17 pm UTC

Apparently the google results are less than informative.

edit: Well, mine are fine, but I choose wikipedia links and Tolkien/fantasy related results quite often, so it may be search engine bias.


Return to “Individual XKCD Comic Threads”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Rossegacebes and 45 guests